Joel Madden and Hilary Duff have broken up. Joel went to club Enclave and openly discussed how the two are no longer an item. Apparantly the couple called it quits over a week ago.
Is Good Charlotte’s Joel Madden no longer mad for Hilary Duff?Madden made a guest DJ appearance at Enclave on Wednesday night and openly talked about how he is currently single. Madden told clubgoers Duff broke up with him about ten days ago and that their eight-year age difference was causing problems. (Madden is 27, Duff is 19.)
After taking over the DJ booth, Madden mingled and took pictures with some ladies. Word is Madden partied at the club until close. (source)
In other news, I’m having server issues again! So sorry! 
hey
i am 15 years old and you cool i am in high school now in the 10th grade its fun i liked wothing your moves when i was little now i dont like woing tv that is all i have to say bye
Well i steill think think that joel is stupid
hey ppl, i am just happy tht i broke up wit joel bcause i too think tht the age diff is a big gap but i am happy to be single bcause its cool!! u ppl shld try it too!!
relly 2 tell u tha truth i think that joel luks prutty decent in tha pic n i think that as long as them 2 r happy we shuld just go with it n even if u think it waz a mistake that they got 2getha/broke up well just no that they r humans 2 n every1 makes mistakes n messes up n we all learn 4 it so if u dont lyk it at least c it as a learning experiance for them n us (tlkin bout the age gap thing n if it wrks/or doesnt wrk)
but gud luk 2 em both they r obviously moving on in their lifes n are treasurein the experiance
peace
okay seriously people get a life and re-read what i said. It may knock some since into people. Stop being so jealous and hatefull and rude. You may love them or hate them but dont hate what they do. Its not your life its there.
So you hate hilary big deal..So you get Joel…Big DEAL..
GROW THE FUCK UP
AND RE-READ THIS!!
Seeing it makes since of how stupid some of you are acting..
"Seriously people get over it..So they broke up..You all act like you have dibs on hilary or joel. If some of you were true fans you wouldnt be hating on wether they were together or not..Be happy for joel and/or hilary if their happy now..you act like they dont talk anymore. Their still friends and all. The only reason you didnt like them to begin with is beacause you were jealous of A. Joel or B. Hilary. Half the teens hating are younger then Hilary 14 15 around there. Come on now lets get serious people. "
excuse me *hate* joel sorry mistype
both are stupid,coz every two in hollywood that hook up will eventually brake up,so why do it in the first place ??
HEY Joel why the hell did you break up with Hilary you are such a <strong>COMMENT MODERATED</strong>
OMG NO WAY! somethin i didnt think would happen *this* year!
i think that they should have stayed together cuz they were soooooooooooooo cute!!!!!!!!!
they seemed perfect for each other and it was sad when i found out about the break up!!!!!
i think that joel is the best and so is hilary but i guess that you can only have one favorite…..
so i choose…..(PETE WENTZ CUZ HE IS HOTTER THEN JOEL)and he seems to be ok with that!!!!!!!!!
Hi! I live much beautiful life and this site make my life is more beauty.
i totally agree!!!!!!! you r like the easyist one to talk to on here!!!:D
Im so glad this b.s. is FInally like SOOOO over.After she met this guy she changed her looks dramatically.His rocker bad boy status was unhealthy for her.I believe she felt insecure from his groupies and thats where her dramatic look came from.But i always disliked him after when hilary was asked if Joel was worried about her dramatic weight loss,she said,no that he likes her this skinny(more like bony).Also,what is it about older men dating young girls?!I think its cause no woman his age would take his crap!For example:"God Hilary your kinda fat,you should really lose some weight."F*uck*ng Loser.Good luck in the future Hilary.Remember just cause theyre older doesnt mean theyre more mature.
haha hilary duff hats jole.s guts and joel dazrvd to bo hated. kieanah
kieanah s rite.
how ever liks joel is so you konw
how ever liks joel is so you konw what.
how are you get a life? rite back
how are you get a life? rite back soon
my name is chayeann and im 15 and im poplur at my school my sister is name is brook kieanah is my sister too if you what to get to no me you can say my name.
dude i thought that this is for break up stuff only?
ok soo what else has happend beetween stars lately?
i think that it.s supostabe about brack up too.
did u know that joel is dateing nicole richie?
its good that they broke up. mabey joel can help nicole richie!
why can’t any of you spell?
Listen up ppl:
) *Best Wishes Hillary and Joel 
*Hillary and Joel are great people.I think they are awesom.But what happened between them is theur private stuff..Dont get me wrong-i think they are cute together…but the question is why they broke up?Because of the age thing right?Maybe they had problems??…..But Dont Say that Joel is Ugly and Stupid or stuff like that..Because if we be like that Hillary would have never been with him!After all i kinda still think that they arent get over each other..Because listen to some Good Charlottes songs and Listen to some Hillarys song..The text is like soOo for each other…For example in “Break apart her heart” Joel sings:”Theres something i dont really understand the only way a woman is gonna want a man the only way u ever keep her in ur hands is break it-apart her heart!” …..and in Hillarys songs for example in “Stranger” or in “Happy” and in “Never stop loving you” the text is totaly for them! ….I think they kinda like each other still…i mean its possible!Of course you will say for somebody that you hate him if you broke up with him…but what you feel inside is very different…But i wont offent anyone because i am a BIG fan of Hillary Duff and Joel Madden so i say they too Rock.And they will allways be one of the BEST Hollywood couples ever…i know that they think like me..I juSt KnoW It! ….but it doesnt seem that Joel doesnt Love Richie..He loves her really much..He just kinda let go Hillary…And she did the same…I hope that one day it will be the same again….
holaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa todos me declaro fanatica de joel maden por eso quiero decir que hyl se veia muy bonita al lado de el eran superr lindos lastima que se le olvido pensar y lo boto.
joel papasoteeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee colombia te quiere becitos a todos los que lean esto
just leave this matter….
love u all
hilary u rock
what fucken ever!!!!!
listen you guys this is no way to say she is wrong!she isint one of my fave,but she did rigt!!!she rules my mind because guys are full of sht!!!!!*
slt ca va moi basima de maroccain ? grooooooooooooo bizoooooooooooooo hillary duff bonne chançe tchawwwwwwww ?
hey joel anda con hil otra vez hacen buena pareja eres un buen chavo y muy guapo y ella tambien ese con el que anda esta bien feo tu esta mas guapo porfiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiis anda con ella otra vez con ella
gaby
fuck u all u fat asses.
WHAT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! do not say that !!!!!!:(
hillary duff u should not wear that drees it shows ur assss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Joel is soooo hot. I would so #@^( him.
osea helloooooooooooooooooo madden no da con la puta mierda ccerota de nicole richie esa jodida y chingona loca esta d lo peor es como un cadaver yyyyyy van a tener un bebe yyyuuuuuuuuuuuuukkkkkk nooooooooo la mera verdad joel da con hilary y no con esa $·!"$&&%/(/""! de nicol rechiche bye kiss
no puedo creer que joel embarazo a la vieja pendeja de nicole,,, que estava pensando cuando lo estava siendo ,, hay que asco ojala que la dege y que le diga que se vaya a la chingada
My Causen Said That If You Aint Got Nothing Good To Say Dont Say Nothing At All.Only For Yall Haters Cause Only Haters Say Rude Stuck Up Stuff Like That.And Shreya Who Ever You Are That Dress Doesnt Show Her Ass Excuse My Language And You Shouldnt Be Looking.
nicole leve joel along hes met to be with hilary
!!!!!!!
I love joel never change, please
i cunt believe you broke up
yous 2 made a really cute couple
but hilary duff is 2 much for joel
anyways im hilary duffs biggest fan
i cunt believe you broke up
yous 2 made a really cute couple
but hilary duff is 2 much for joel
anyways im hilary duffs biggest fan
These jailbait/barely-legal starlets dating older men really bothers me. Sure, starlets get exposed to more faster, but they still have so much to experience; how can they and the older men possibly be appealing to each other?
Maybe it goes back to high school, when 23 year olds and guys even older would date my 14 and 16 year old friends.
haha joel is a loser. good job hilary !!! =D
joel is not a looser ur a dumbass hes a great guy and so is his brother and fellow band mates u suck
poor joel shes a bitch but she didnt deseve him neways
i think its good that these two have finallly broken up because i wanted joel for myself. now i can make him mine
omg this is the best thing i ever heard omg im so happy that they r over !!!!
Aww – all break ups are sad.
but I must say, winter IS the official breakup/hook up season. *shrug*
Seriously people get over it..So they broke up..You all act like you have dibs on hilary or joel. If some of you were true fans you wouldnt be hating on wether they were together or not..Be happy for joel and/or hilary if their happy now..you act like they dont talk anymore. Their still friends and all. The only reason you didnt like them to begin with is beacause you were jealous of A. Joel or B. Hilary. Half the teens hating are younger then Hilary 14 15 around there. Come on now lets get serious people.
I still find "hilary duff" to be synonymous with "lizzie maguire"… so yeah… this adult type dating stuff just weirds me out with hilary duff
Well im still sticking with what i have tos ay
i hate nocole
i wunder hilary nevr sis nothing no moer
i wunder hilary nevr sis nothing no moer.
what the holy carpoltunnle does that mean???
it look like we have somthing in comemt
i wander whay joel dumt hilary for nicole
joel didnt dump hilary!!! hilary dumped joel!!!
and i really dont know how nicole fits into this?!?!
joel didnt dump hilary!!! hilary dumped joel!!!
and i really dont know how nicole fits into this?!?!
but whatever it doesnt really matter
shu up they broke up theres more important things in life than 2 ppl breaking up 4 example wars ppl dieing those are serious not 2 ppl that have broke up i like both of them and u dont see me makeing a big deal now move on with ur ad pethetic little lifes and get over the fact that JOEL MADDEN and HILARY DUFF are not dateing
dude BITE ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!
dude no!!!!
although ppl may agree with me here the only reason im typing in this blog thing is down 2 the fact my m8 is totaly devoted to joel but i think he and she can do better than each other 4 example some1 there age if joel or hilary thought it wasnt workin out then thats that it was obvious me and my bf didnt work out due to a hole 3 year argument of 9 year age diff so thats that now leave this to that or u honestly have no social life or u have 2 much spare time
dude whatever!!!!
i hat the name mariah its so sevendes.
I am glad they are over because Hilary is still a childish, fake, skinny white horse who needs to take that stick out of her ass.
yeah well chayenne isnt much better!!!!!!!!!!!(looser)
I think that Joel is too much for her… I think that he is a very cute man and he deservs a Woman that make him feel better………….
hi whats your problum mariah or sevendes boy shud i shou say.
i hat my sister
ok well first off do you mean hate?(not to be rude at all so sorry if it is)?!?!?!
i agree!!!!
hilary,
I think you made a good choice. you and joel are not a good couple.
sara
Look people are right about you guys you need to stop being obsessed with their lives its not worth it. I was one of you guys because of something that happened but thats not your business. I thought if I was obsessed with their lives my problems would go away but they didnt. I tried anything and everything to get my mind of the bad. But um people as they tell you told me not worry about people who I cant have. Look get over it you will never get a chance to be with them. Your either to young or your gay but whatever the case stop chasing them because the arent going to chase you. I have to admit I was happy when they broke up but I havent talk about since I heard the news that day. I can careless because I have a lot of things going on in my life. Please just get over it and get on with your lives. They arent worth it. I mean they arent worth it to me.
hey losers i love me little sisters dont turn thum in to freaks. later
look peeps joel will help nicole and she will get back on track and then he will dump her! so its either she dies r not!
what ever
i hate them both! they both suck! so why should we all care? hhmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm?????
this is for hilary , i hope she reads it …
you´re a really special girl you know , you have a very unique charisma that attracts people to you cuz you seem yourself , you´re extremely gorgeous and beautiful . but serously now why would you get this thin , my god , you realy had a great body and a fantastic face , well am a guy and i say if a guy says to girl like you with your previous body to get thiner then he has some sereous issues , anyways i wish you the best and one more thing , do what you realy wanna do not what others want you to do . good luck sweet girl
dudettes chill
I like and Hilary Duff,and Joel Madden,but he didn`t have to curse at her that way either. I mean it`s not her fault that she does not feel uncomfortable with the age difference,and Hilary doesn`t need to be rude agreeing with Kieanah either.I actually thought that one day you guy`s would get married.I mean you two make a good couple. PS.You`re still my idol.
omg..hi ok ur prob. dont read this but..wow dont be like Lindsay Lohan..ur better then that..it seems to me like ur more Christian..u really and a normal girl with real dreams just wantted to tell u alway had God in ur hart..i know u can do it..dont ever think..Lindsay Lohan is better then u..u always done things first and she always copys and u always do it better..but u both a egual to GOD..never forget that..bye GOD BLESS U!! w.b to my e-mail.
dude jucy???
YOUR A BUTT WADE FOR THINKING THAT JUST CUZ YOU DONT LIKE HIM DOESNT MEAN THAT OTHER PEOPLE FEEL THE SAME WAY!!!!!!!!!
BESIDES HILARY SUCKS AND JOEL ROCKS @ EVERYTHING HE HAS/WILL EVER DO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i agree with cutie pie!!!
****CHILL*****
wow thats weird ya when did they break up
is joel gay???
wow thats weird ya when did they break up
is joel gay???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
love me
love me losers.
no clover joel is sooo not gay!!!!
he
joel&hilary werent ment 4 each other…2 me i think he sould be with my sister Amber A. Armstrong..(and yes were related to Billie Joe Armstrong)And hilary sould be with Aaron Carter….
YO MAMA
thank god they broke up she is so ugly
i think your ugley Ava have you likt in a mear latly
hey hilary dont be depressed ur 2 good 4 joel!!!!way better !!!!!!!u rock!!!!
I do not understand English but there is no problem when the love is understood.m… bye
I do not understand English but there is no problem when the love is understood.
harreyyhhbbbnnnnhhgfvhjkjk
i hat you
and hes going out with nicole richie now….geez poor joel. all the skinny girls seem to be attracted to him. well they were bound to break up anyway…they were a horrible couple. hes punky, shes…….not. haha.
have fun nicole, human toothpick.
theyre not going to last two weeks.
theyre just not meant to be. nicole should dat wilmer *lmao* and hilary should date…..jesse mcFARTNEY, UNless ashley tisdale gets him first. in that case, hilary should date zac, even though hes in love with vanessa who is secretley dating eminem! okay i made that vanessa thing up. but benji madden is dating nicky hilton. wow i would feel bad for hilary if joel started dating haylie…… maybe hilary should date benji…noo…. paris hilton should totally date whats his face…orlando bloom. no wait thats ashley olsen. mary kate should date ashton kutcher and paris should date adam brody. and ashley olsen should date orlando bloom.
how do i know all this stuff?
omg im so sad that they broke up too.. i really love them together and they are sooo the cutest couple in the world… out of all the celeb couples, thats one couple that i wanted to stay together…
i love her and him together.. IM SO SAD!shes my hero!
i think hilary duff and joel were a great couple and they were happy together and now i think they seem happy apart and in end it is up to them if they want to split or stay together you only live once so you want to be happy during your life dont you and if that means you have to split you have to split and who are we to judge them
comment number 121 was writen by kathryn
JOEL MADDEN IS A SXY BITCH AND A TOTAL BITCH FOR BREACKIN UP WITH HILARY
oh my goodness, theres so many comments on this thread!
fall out boy has nothing to do with this.
omg comment 117 is pretty funny i think
yes yes joel was a bitch for dumping hilary but just look
((((
at the age difference u could tell they would never get married
or hav a never ending life together
so its a broken heart for hilary but she can hav
any guy she wants shes gawgus
i think she matched greatwith oliver james
from raise ur voice so theres others guys out there for u !!!
Thank god they broke up… he was or IS too WRONG and UGLY for her she need a real man next to her:)…
I really think that it is the best way for her…
he don"t deserve she. he is so ugly for her. She can to have any boy who she want…………………
it don`t suprise me at all she just wanted help for her talent she dosent have a good talent therfore she used Joel I think. I am not jealus at her but I think that the age it`s just some excuse to break up with him, I have good friends that have boyfriends and girlfriends with huge age difference so that is what I have got to say… tanx
and by the way Hilary dumped him. and Joel is a SEXY MAN !!!
hillary and joel lasted more then two years is wat i read and when i heard they broke up i was in shock sorry to say but i think joel is stupid for gooing to a party without hilary and i dont blam hilary for breaking up with him and here i thought that they would last forever and get married but no joel had to go be himself and go to a party without hilary and hilary thought something maybe went on over there. that joel was keeping a secret well wat ever
bye.
Hilary and Joel were together for over 2 years and here i thought they would be together forever . so when i heard they broke up i was in shock. and this is all Joels fault because he went to a party without hilary and what kind of couple is that. So what my guess is that Hilary thought something was going on and so joel just broke up with her and i mean who does that. but if you look at the good side it is kind of a good thing because there age difference is so far apart. so joel is stupid is what i figured out thanks for chatting
bye.
JOEL IS A JERK AND THATS ALL THERE IS TO IT!!!!!!!!
JOEL IS A JERK AND THATS ALL THERE IS TO IT!!!!!!!!
hi pepole what are you doing I WILL TELL YOU WHAT YOU ARE DONIN IAM LIKE LEAVE JOEL AND HILRAY ALONE YOU CARES IF THERE NOT DATING MAN YOU GUYS
hey i am glad hilary broke up with joal jaol is a asshole so there
I think it is really sad that they have broaken up! Caus I think they looked really cute together!
iuh i know, but still know she calls nicole a bitch and eather shes really mad or she still loves him. I mean its been 3 months i guess shes still in love wirh him and they will get back together!
But I mean Hilary is really weird I mean she broake up with HIM, and know he is having fun with Nicole Richie
It so sad they broke up but,love is love.
It so sad they broke up but,love is love.
i think love is love nd they were just not ment to be so they both have to take that………..
joel u on crack u shud still be with hillary………………o n good charlotte,,greenday,mcr are the bst bands eva cnt w8 4 good moring revial:D
I am glad for HIlary because I do not like Joel
aee joel, u rok thx 4 brakin up wit her shes gay u rok JOEL!!!!! ur soooo kool
losers
hey joel why you changed hilary for nicole?
it´s the only tht i can say.
hey joel, why you changed hilary for nicole?
it´s the only tht i can say.
ı thınk hilary dont deserve joeL becase joeL misslead hilary with nicole richie . ihate nicole she ıs fukıng bitch ang ugly. hilary go and find another handsome boy he dont deserve you.you are ma idol.ı love you baby you deserve better than dis ugly fuckın man
im so not a fan
iook i like hilary and joel is a stuped purson.
you shund be on hear when your not a fan then boo you.
u know, they were cute 2gther, but people break up, stuff happens. big deal.
joel is pretty hot though..but thats OFF TOPIC! haha
where did you people learn spelling and basic grammar?
y do u not kno how 2 read it????
how could u possibly understand some of the stuff u guys wrote?! it makes no sense whatsoever!!
well look at twhat you just wrote!!!!
i hate you gays
oh so now ur calling us gay thanks soooooooooo much cuz i hate you to!!!
ummm… yeah fall out boy sooooo does rock but hilary and pete NO FREAKIN WAY she is soooooooo not right for him and trust me i know!!!!
i love hillary duff!!!
i like her films and songs:)
Hilary Duff is the best mann! i dnt knoo why she was goink out wit dat guy joal his such a ring parson if use knoo wat mee meann anyways I just love Hilary i wuvv her new song play with fire and it sounded as if it was made for joal was it?? g2g see yas
hi pizzbug 982 have you lookt in a mearr latley hate me but love mostley
hahahah funny chayenne what kind of name is pizzabug928 that is gay later josh
ha ha ha if your on this then your gay you loser!!!!
today i am going to say whats right joel is a loser and thats all there is to it he dumped hilary to go out with a skinny twig lets hear it NICOLE RICHIE who in the world would want to go out with her
I think that Joel Madden has always been a loser. Hilary deserves a whole lot flipping better. The are ceartain guys that she would have a perfect match with like: Chad Michael Murray. I also have ALWAYS wanted here to date Jesse McCartney.
apperently he does and he isnt a loser he is really nice!!
well i herd that she broke up with him cuz he wanted to have sexual reletionships and he insisted but she got tired of him
how liks pizzabug982 because i dont.
oh thank you soooooooo much now another person has been a jerk off to me!!!
what ever loser .
why the heck are you so mean to me??
what did i ever do to you??
wow you must be the smartest person in here
wow your nice to that is soo much better then alot of the jerks that are on here
good charlotte i love
I LoVe jOeL MAddeN end niCoLe RiChIe
good charlotte rock
I LoVe jOeL MAddeN end niCoLe RiChIe
good charlotte rock
all you are gay grow up all reddy thay brok up so get over it
all you are gay grow up all reddy thay brok up so get over it . not chayenne thow ok naw shut up all redy
your a freakin jerk face dont ever talk to us again we r all greaving over it!!!!
my friend hannah said that she really doesnt care and that she loves you(josh not chyanne)
tell hannah she gots a cute name ok and you get off little bug hahaha
ok i told her and what??
im not famus…….. are you ?
why is this josh even on hear ????
who knows maybe hes gay or something??!!!
true hahaha
im dating all redy im daing and hes cute how wants to gess ?
wotever..joel was too old for her..newayz hez sucha junkie..eww:S:P
oh snap that is sooooooooo funny!!!
your dad is a purv thats grose
who r u going 2 date next?
i wonder who Hilary is going to date next?hopefully things will work out good enough 4 her and i hope it is someone that she likes and isnt so freeky lookin but does realy nice things 4 her to! -March 2nd,2007@11:50pm
i think joel and hilary make a very cute and fun couple but joel being 8 years older doesnt sound right to me but i wish you guys luck cause you guys look so cute and fun together!!!
xoxo cutie pie
what ever loser
Why did you break up with joel?
will first he brockup with me so that means he love"d nicole not me we have to move on thats why notbe rood ro nothing later love hilary
oh really ok then thats clear
OH shut up ugley NICOLE!!!!!!! you cant even tell how joel loves you think your better then hilary but your really not in my maegazen it says joel miet still love hilary duff so NOT YOU!!!!! hilary duff is way much better this ant about you it;s about hilary duff and stuped joel.
oh yea
what ever
it was not hilary duff that said that it was me lol esey target hahaha loser naw shut up !!!
oh so hannah love"s me cool
hey. hilary is ok and im glad you guys split up . joel does take drugs cause i seen him on one of their websites and hilary is too smart. i want to see you hilary! but hilary is abit sick cause of the video of the other website she was kissing antoher guy. hilary you got to read this. isaw on a magazine that nicole was having sex with joel and she send you a photo of them saying gorgoues photo or whatever so dont like JOEL!
Sorry says-
They were cute, shes a princess and hes her prince. They are perfect for each other!!! Nicole Richie is UGLY and such a bitch what a back stabber. I hope they become a couple again soon!!!!!
Love ya!!!!!!
Sorry says-
They were cute, shes a princess and hes her prince. They are perfect for each other!!! Nicole Richie is UGLY and such a bitch what a back stabber. I hope they become a couple again soon!!!!!
Love ya!!!!!!
be nice to me or alcse i will kick you in the butt!!! lol
what ever christina stay out fo it luozey christina hahah at you lol
ummm so….. i hate joel
i think they both suck butttt!!!!!, 1st of all hilary duff is an anorexic try hard who only cares about wutever ne1 else thinks instead of wut she thinks….it bothers me, she was fine before!!!, 2nd of all joel madden….ewww! hes like a wannabe punk guy who thinks hes all cool and shit cuz hes got a band….hes not!!!! okay i think iv done enough insulting 2day but truth be told they were a lame couple and they both suck butttt!!! lol
Who says that this is the reason they broke up? 95% of gossip is false….
Someone who hates both…why do you hate? you dont know anything about them. can u honestly say that you sat down with both of them and got to know them?
umm i know about hear she liks the culer green and she is 19 years old hear middle name is ann she gots a sister namd haylie duff and she is very nice soo thar !!!
get over it that is old news so…. oh yea how ever hate "s hilary give hear a chance you dont know hear well so think about that .
I think Joel and Hilary looked cute together, but I guess it was just time to move on. Plus, the whole age thing was sort of odd.
joel te ves lindo pero q mala onda q ronpieron hasian muy bonita pareja
esto me da envidia esta bien guapote joe
i totally!..agree with Jackie.
this is life ppl?..sometimes; love just comes and goes.
what ever larissa is ugley name ops did i say it out loud lol later………
is joel madden the lead of simple plan
hey guys get a life!!!!
personally I like hiary more than joel. Hilary you rockkk and joel you are not that bad. i didn’t like the idea of they two together but what can i do is not like hilary is going to pay attention to how we think i personally i get mad when i read that someone thinks hilary is a bitch or a jurk because she is not i know her i’d talk to her and first stop writting that bad stuff about hilary or joel cause both of are good. second start paying attention of what is happening in yor life and then what is on someone else life
uhm I am not engelisch but I am from holland
I speakinhg duchts .
uhm ik vind good charlotte geweldig en joel
heeft hilary helemaal niet nodig vind ik dan er zijn nog genoeg meiden in de wereld en joel you are not stopid I love Joel And Benji and I hate Hilary srry Hilary nou ik haat je nou ook weer niet maar joel is veeeeeell leuker dan jou snietsel!haha…groetejes my AmberTjuh!!
uhm I Am Not engelisch but i`am from holland
i´am speaking duchts.
ik vind good charlotte echt helemaal geweldig
en joel you are not stopid I love Joel ANd Benji
en Joel er lopen nog genoeg meiden rond in de wereld hoor hilary is niet de enige meid.
en joel je ontmoet vast wel weer een leuke meid leuker dan hilary denk ik en hoop ik.
Joel you are cool and Benji you are cool I hate hilary srry hilary najaa ik haat hilary niet maar ik vind der niet echt leuk vette snietsel dat je
bent hilary doeidoei groetjes aan Joel And Benji en Zeg maar dat komt van Amberdebruin die woont in nederland en dan in friesland en ik ben 12 ahah jong he! doeidoiei groetjes amberdebruin
OMG I LUV HILARY DUFF SHE IS DA BEST EVA WOWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW MUAH XXXXXXXXX
im so sad to hear da news.they r the perfect couple.they look good together.im a big fan of Good Charlotte n i always love Hilary.I want u guys to go back together.JOEL,u do u have to choose NICOLE RICHIE??? DUFF is so much BETTER!!!!
hlfgh
hi love so werd on tv sand me.
ola me llamo rebeca hilary eres la megor aki en españa te tenemos muy balorada podrias tener un novio español son muy atractivos.
mukas frnkiu
it was really good thing tht you both broke up
=P i am a big fan of you lots of love
lub maryam
I love you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i love you
I love you. Marry me at 2012. Engage me.
You in my heart. Kiss me. Hug me.
From Alex.
Joel Madden is a loser.
you guys are making a big deal about this im fine its over. but joel is a FUCKING ASSHOLE!!!
FUCK YOU ALL WHO SAY JOEL IS A LOSER! I HATE HILARY DUFF AND THINKS SHE NEEDS TO DIE! anyway, im happy they broke up, Joel deserves better…but i also dont like Nicole Richie either, i dont think they should be dating…are there any decent girls left in Hollywood for poor Joel?
Good job hilary. you shoudnt went out with him in the first place. Hes goth.
HeII.. I LovE HilArY.. SO WhoEvEr IS SAyIn DaT ShE Is StUpId.. FUCK U!.. AnD I ALsO FuCkIn LoVe JoeL.. He Is So0 SeXii… I ThoUghT ThEy WeRe So0 SeXii.. OmG.. BuT NiCoLE Is Jus StUpID AnD ReTaRtED…. So0 DUFf Is WaY BeTtEr.. I JuS LoVE ThEm BoTh… So I thOuGht ThEy WeRe So0 CuTe TogRthEr… But LikE AlWaYs It ComEs To An EnD… DaTs HoW LiFe IssSs!!… BuT I ThInK ThEy ShOuLd Get BaCk ToGeThEr… ââ„¢¥ââ„¢¥ââ„¢¥ââ„¢¥ LovE U!!!! [HaZ3L]
hilary duff eres la mujer mas bonita y dulce que he visto en mi vida…………….claro que despues de mi….en serio me encanta tu musica y que sigas asi siempre te quiero mucho angie restrepo de colombia angiemetal66@hotmail.com
lol omg this is fing hilarious there is 271 comments that people who are maybe just a little over bored with thisw whole subject wrote
thats funny
it doesnt suprise me,
sorry hillary but you kan get e better guy!!!!
he is uglie!!!
end the dont matsch.
Hi :: Man Irani Hastam :: Eshghe Man Hillary Jo0o0o0o0o0oNe :: Kheili Dooosesh DAram :: Movafagh Bashe :: I Love You Hilary 4 Ever
nima manam irani hastam manam kheili hilary doestaram!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i think hilary should be with aaron carter to……..
dfiskdfhuukjgruk
HEY HILARY DUFF WE ALL LOVE YOU I HOPE YOU HAVE FUN WITH WHAT YOU HAVE TO COME FORFILL YOUR DEAMS AND DO WHATEVA YOU WANT TO DO FORGET WHAT OTHER PPL SAY TO YOU
LOTS OF LOVE ASHLEY xoxoxoxoxox
hillary ur so SKINNY MAN u were better wen u was small oh yh hillary u deserve someone better
Joel is the best and GC rocks forever!!!!
hi i think it is good that hil broke up with that bastered he is a coward go hil find a new boyfriend that is the same age as u 27 is few alot more than 18
good charlotte are seriously good but its their music u like u dont even know how joel madden is off camera or outside the stories same with hilary duff leave them alone its their life NOT YOURS people who are rude jealous and nosy
joel sos el amor de mi vida… lo unico que no me gusta es que estes con esa chica… no es para vos… buscate una como la gente mi amor… yo estoy totalmente sola para vos… hacemos lo que quieras…
Hilary Duff eres muy bonita y creo que te mereces a una persona mejor qe joel madden, aunque a mi me guste good charlotte y creo que joel madden es muy guapo:) sigo pensando que vales mas y que el no te merece por que tu te mereces encontrar a un chico mucho mejor y que te quiera sin pensar en el sexo ¬¬. Joel esta de romance con nicole porque ella solo se fija en su popularidad, en que todo el mundo este a su alrededor. ella toma drogas, bebe mucho y es mala persona. yo no entiendo en que joel se fija en ella :S por que mira que es fea eee lol lol lol jejejej bueno de decirte que te encuentres a un xico muy guapo:D
hilary duff u done it good, girl u can get some one more hottter and younger then joel your way too good for him so keep your head high love you
biggest fannnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
i dont think that nicole and joel should be together !!!!! hilary is so nice nicole is a supermean girl and i dont like her
They Belong Together Hilary+Joel=Love
Nossaa!!!! será que ninguem aqui fala a minha lÃngua !! rsrsrs
naum to consiguindo entender nada do que os outros escrevem.
Ingles também naum eh o meu forte!!! huahuahua.
YOU GUYS R SO RIGHT WITH YOUR OPINIONS I LIKE DUFF CUZ SHE PRETTY BUT JOEL WAS 2 OLD AND I KNOW THEY SAY AGE IS JUST A NUMBER BUT IT CAN CAUSE SOME SERIOUS TROUBLE
I THINK HILARY IS SOOOO STUPID BECAUSE SHE BROKE UP WITH THE HOTTEST GUY ON EARTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
DAMN JOEL IS F@#$ING FINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Honesty, integrity and a persuasive mentality are the most important qualities of an elected official
hilary duff is the bst and i think her and joel were good to gether but e is no way fit lol
she is also not stupid for leavin him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i love hilary duff 4 lyf
i am glad that my cute girlfriend broke-up with her old boyfriend from
Good Charlotte name is Joel Madden and i love you Hilary Duff.
Talk to your dad and i promise to keep you forever.
You broke-up with Nicole and Joel Madden from Good Charlotte.
You are my favorite cute girlfriend.
Just talk to me and talk about me.
I will sing with you.
i love you so much Hilary I will send you some emails tonight love you.
I will dream about you tonight.
I HATE JOEL BUT I LOVE GOOD CHARLOTTE N BENJI N BILLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!ROCK ON GC(GOOD CHARLOTTE) WHO HERE LOVE GOOD CHARLOTTE??????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hi I am a big fan of u I am 10 years old I am a qatery girl I love sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much and very much very very much u are soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo cool and hate and qute I love u voyes I love ur tato is sooooooooooooo cool oh I love u sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much and very much and I dont care what u were I alwas care sbout u my best song is the anthem I love its oh my god I love u so much jole if I will visit amarica I will take anongrafe and a piceture okay take cere and good luck okay so bye