Love It Or Hate It: Hilary Duff
Hilary Duff has been sporting this look a lot lately...talls boots with short shorts. What do you think of the style? Is it a hit or a miss in your book?
And by the way, in these shots she's out to breakfast at Papoos Hot Dog stand, for the second time in four days. Has anyone ever been there because I'd love to know what the deal is and why Hilary's so addicted! :)
Photos by Bauer Griffin













I think it is a miss. It is just not her style.
The shirt kinda looks like she's gained a little weight and is trying to hide it. she's a gorgeous girl, but that color does nothing for her.
Yeah, she's chuby again...
2560 points
i understand not everyone can be made up all the time, but i don't like the outfit at all. britney spears early trainwreck days come to mind. Hilary is usually a little more put together than this, so it's just odd to see her so disheveled
hot dogs for breakfast?
mmmkay
I do not like her bubble gum music and who wears boots in the summer time unless one wants sweaty feet!
HAPPY 66th BIRTHDAY PAUL McCARTNEY!
THANK YOU FOR THE BEATLES, WINGS, AND YOUR CURRENT MUSIC TOO!
THE BEATLES ARE THE GREATEST ROCK BAND IN HISTORY!
A NEW BEATLES FAN IS BORN EVERYDAY!
the beatles suck dick and I would let hillary suck mine
905 points
I'm not a fan of the ripped shorts look the boots I don't mind - but that shirt is ill fitting.
I like the boots+shorts look but just not today. this outfit isn't flattering at all.
Um, I think you can tell she loves the hotdog stand! The outfit looks...disheveled. I usually don't mind short skirt with boots, but this outfit just looks bad.
300 points
definite miss :(
And I love the duffster! But yeah, this outfit is all kinds of wrong.
I want to go to Papoos Hot Dog! Sounds yummy!
This outfit makes her look so bad. Why????????????????????? She is one of my fashion Icons. This look makes her look so bad, but maybe it was just a hot day and she wanted to wear as little as possible. But I still love her!
She looks more like she did in her Lizzie McGuire days- young and a little heavier- which I think suits her more than rake thin with those big ol' hollywood teeth!
It's a miss!!
shes put on weight and the main area is her face!
She looks a tad messier than usual. And its nice to see her with some meat on her bones again. She was looking too thin not too long ago.
she cant pull that off...
blake lively can..but not her.
9355 points
I like short skirts and tall boots... but not shorts.
hate it.
Boy she really does love those hot dogs. It's showing.
510 points
she looks messy & she has definitely gained weight, which is fine because she was looking scary skinny there for a bit. i think kate moss has pulled off the tall boots with shorts, it just takes a certain style to do it successfully & this isnt it.
oh hillary no! way too pudgy for that horrific outfit
she looks great as usual and she's make up less she's one of the few that can go outside without looking make up and still look great everyone has those days where they don't look their best she's normal she can't be glamed up 24/7 give her break she's on vacation just let her relax
300 points
*yawn* all the comments about loving to eat hot dogs were so predictable.
800 points
She looks a healthy weight, as for the outfit...horrible!!
890 points
I agree. It's a much better weight than she once was. She should stay around this weight in my opinion.
when I first glanced at the picture I thought she had on a Wonder Woman costume, so I would say it is a miss.
Of course I hate it. But with her looks, what'll look good? Probably not much. Otis Rail
i didn't even recognize her--she totally chubbed out.
9545 points
beyotch stole my purse!
30215 points
these photos are unflattering.
300 points
if she gained weight it doesnt show in her legs at all. maybe the hot dogs are like breakfast tacos?. shes cute! I would never suggest anyone wear cutoffs and boots though, thats pretty tacky looking.
473407 points
Not my favorite color on her, but I still think she's a cute girl.
Don't sweat the petty stuff and don't pet the sweaty stuff :)
Once porky, always porky. Why do naturally round women try to lose weight. There are lots of men who like them the way they are. Now look at Hillary, she's clearly into the ice cream tub again.
Hilary is not fat!!!!!!!1 what the hell i feel bad for her she can never please anyone with her weigh first people criticized her 4 years ago because she looked chubby then she lost weight and people were saying she had a eating disorder than Hilary starts to gain some healthy weight people are calling her fat again what the fuck?!
I SAW THIS PICTURE YESTERDAY AND BOUGHT THE EXACT OUT FIT CAUSE I LOVE TO COPY ALL THE UGLY CLEBERTYS TO MAKE THEM LOOK WORSE CAUSE IM SOOOO HOTT I MEAN IM HOTTWITH 2 T'S AND SHES NOT WITH 2 T'S P.S IM A UGLY COPY CAT BITCH
IM A FAT AS BITCH WHO LOVES TO COPPY BITCHES COME FUCK ME
Y'know girls, a big part of havin' nice legs is in the knees. Look at Duffer's knees for instance here. Big, bloated and wide. Not good. Otis Rail
haters can keep hating because you wish you looked good like Hilary she has a slamming body she is skinny with great curves i bet most of the girls who are commenting have bodies likes boys with no curves and a flat butt and no boobs
1140 points
I love her outfit- minus the boots. Everything else is cute! I actually noticed that it looks like she gained a little weight, but it works to her advantage. She looks much better here with a little meat on her bones, instead of stick thin.
exactly she's healthy she's neither skinny nor near being fat
I think she might be pregnant... Her boyfriend might have pressured her to have babays!
I actually like everything but the boots cause they are not this season.....they are for fall. It's not the greatest shirt, but it isn't THAT bad. I can't believe ppl are making comments about her weight?! She is slender and petite. You must be blind.
first call your an idiot she is not pregnant
300 points
i see a picture of a girl wearing leather boots in los angeles in june and i think of sweaty toe jam and the awkwardness of needing to wash your feet mid-heavy make out
wait till you see how great she looked at the Cartier's event
If this is "chubbed out" than I am all for it! She looks healthy and happy! The outfit itself is, however, completely unflattering. With all of her $$ it'd be wise to not pull an Olsen Twin and dress hobo chic... I totally understand wanting to "dress down" but perhaps she should strive to look more like Eva Longoria... who does casual so beatifully...
3230 points
Wow! I almost thought this was a contest with all the comments! Yes, not good pics at all! She's still a cutie though.... just looks "normal" here.
Looks like a bag lady!
She needs a tan, the top is ugly-period. If she had a tight white v-neck tee shirt it might work. She has gained some weight, and looks good where she is...just watch sloppy look...adds more bulk!
I'm not usually one to say this...but she looks like she's gaining some weight. Maybe eating hot dogs for breakfast isn't such a good idea.
i think those are her fat shorts
i think those are her fat shorts
5655 points
She usually looks great but the top I think is just wrong for her in terms of colour and cut. Then again, she may have been rushing out and just threw the frst thing she could find on, or simply not in the mood for dressing up. I always think that celebs need to be given a bit of space when it comes to their outfits as they just cannot be that well dressed all the time.
Post new comment
When commenting, please be respectful to other INO readers. No racial, sexual or homophobic slurs will be tolerated.