Love It Or Hate It: Maggie Gyllenhaal's Tatler Cover

Love It Or Hate It: Maggie Gyllenhaal's Tatler Cover

What does everyone think of Tatler's cover shot with Maggie Gyllenhaal? Did they make her look the best she could? The lighting and make up is an interesting combo, right?

Love it or Hate it?



COMMENTS...

Passerby Passerby said:

She looks like The Joker!!! (Not Heath but The Joker)

<a href="/user/94" title="View user profile.">acarroll</a>
945 points
acarroll said:

I was thinking the same thing.

Passerby Passerby said:

Me Too!!! I dunno if that was the desired effect...

<a href="/user/2966" title="View user profile.">Allie615</a>
1310 points
Allie615 said:

Her pale skin almost disappears against the white background. And her eyes look scary with all that eyeliner. It'd be pretty upset about this cover if I were her.

PardyHardy
555 points
PardyHardy said:

Oh my god. I thought she looked like the Joker too!! That's crazy.

Stina Stina said:

Kinda Jokerish. If the background color was a deep red, I think it would be a really good photo. Her white skin and the white background is too washed out. But her eyes are such a pretty color!

Passerby Passerby said:

I agree with her looking kinda Jokerish. She also looks kinda bobbleheady on top of that, but it could be just the hair.

Passerby Passerby said:

I dont find her attactive at all. All the make up & lighting cant help her face.

Passerby Passerby said:

Looks like the joker...

<a href="/user/117" title="View user profile.">Sarah O.</a>
1935 points
Sarah O. said:

If her eyes just had some color then it wouldn't be horrible. And change the red lipstick... But you have to admit she is beautiful.

Passerby Passerby said:

her makeup makes her look like the joker.

WHY? WHY? said:

THE JOKER'S WIFE ,,,

<a href="/user/278" title="View user profile.">Miss_M</a>
300 points
Miss_M said:

What on earth did they do to Maggie? They should sack the stylist and make-up artist.

Passerby Passerby said:

kinda look like linda blair from the exorcist. what's with the white eyes???

<a href="/user/427" title="View user profile.">annielovesfred</a>
300 points
annielovesfred said:

She's a bit avant garde herself. So I think anything goes with this chick. A bit goth like batman!
PS is it just me or is that movie a bit too hyped? I thought it was too long and gary oldman stole the show.

lO lO said:

ER, YEAH. joker ala heath anyone? god they abused her naturally unattractive face to heinous proportions.

passerby passerby said:

OMG! She looks like the next Batman villian -- the Joker's sister, Jester. She's fug to begin with and this cover does her NO justice~

<a href="/user/3162" title="View user profile.">gretel</a>
2660 points
gretel said:

If they were going for the Joker style, then they've made a great job.

Anonymous Anonymous said:

You mean that's a real picture? I thought it was a caracature (sp.?). It's horrible, whatever it is.

Passerby Passerby said:

OH MY GOD! She has always looked like a Muppet to me, but this is horrible. I feel bad for her she is legitimately ugly.

<a href="/user/397" title="View user profile.">momster</a>
12080 points
momster said:

I think that Maggie is a very pretty girl (woman?) who makes interesting fashion choices and the bottom line is that she is not particularly photogenic, unfortunately.

rtenney01
300 points
rtenney01 said:

too much armpit, and she really does look like the joker-reincarnate

Passerby Passerby said:

it's funny, she kinda looks like the Joker.

Passerby Passerby said:

she's not a traditional beauty, but i tink she is uniquely beautiful. But that photo doesn't do her any justice at all. I think they were definetly going for the joker look.

Passerby Passerby said:

Wow, I do not know about babe I do see she looks like a Joker. Aside from that she looks like a grandma with her droopy eyes in real life whn not photoshopped.

Passerby Passerby said:

Horrifying! Eek....

Passerby Passerby said:

Horrifying! Eek....

<a href="/user/84" title="View user profile.">tbtrfli</a>
3230 points
tbtrfli said:

AWFUL!!!!!! OMG!

<a href="/user/2234" title="View user profile.">dyinggiraffe</a>
13985 points
dyinggiraffe said:

the tattler wronged her...

Passerby Passerby said:

SCARY!!!!!

<a href="/user/118" title="View user profile.">duraznito</a>
1095 points
duraznito said:

She looks strange, i don`t like de eye make up, she`s looking a little bit like the jocker, but the dress is pretty.

Jesser Jesser said:

I think she could of looked very pretty but it kinda makes her look like the joker with the lighting...:S

Linda Linda said:

Like everyone else, I thought she looked like the joker when I saw the picture. I don't think Maggie is very pretty but this picture makes her look horrible.

mica mica said:

i like her, but in this picture, she remind me of the joker!!!!!

<a href="/user/200" title="View user profile.">Jen.number2</a>
330 points
Jen.number2 said:

I think they did an awful job, there is no excuse for a cover like that.

<a href="/user/745" title="View user profile.">gia</a>
510 points
gia said:

she is already not a very pretty girl & this photo is making that more vivid!
i hated her in Batman. true, her acting was a little better than katie holmes, but really now doesnt Batman deserve a true beauty? inside & out. i dont know why that role seemed so difficult to cast properly.

<a href="/user/598" title="View user profile.">sherry</a>
1115 points
sherry said:

Wow. Not very flattering at all.

<a href="/user/2222" title="View user profile.">suffy_78</a>
5315 points
suffy_78 said:

One word, SCARY....

<a href="/user/3384" title="View user profile.">starlitbetty</a>
2375 points
starlitbetty said:

well, if they were trying to promote the dark knight they did a good job because she looks as scarey as heath ledger did in the movie! I do love that dress and color on her though...

<a href="/user/763" title="View user profile.">greeeneyedwhwoman</a>
1375 points
greeeneyedwhwoman said:

Is that serious makeup on her?? or jokerish makeup? I have to say I'm not a fan of that picture at all

Passerby Passerby said:

Frightful. Looks like Maggie was trying out for the Joker part here.

<a href="/user/2220" title="View user profile.">Nimbus</a>
25 points
Nimbus said:

I think she looks like a stick insect with a human head super imposed on it.... add a bit of photo shop (or a lot) and hey presto....

Jennifer w Jennifer w said:

She's ugly anyway with or without airbrushing. The pig nose and goofy ass cheeks makes her incredibly unfortunate in the looks dept, but this makes her look as if she's in makeup for the next Batman as the Joker.

Raedient Raedient said:

Seriously has she taken on heath ledgers role of the Joker..Thsis the worst i haveever seen gyllenhal normallyshe s a stunner

Passerby Passerby said:

wow she scares me on this photo, she has a face so special, but we used to see her looking her best

Passerby Passerby said:

I thought this is how Maggie has always looked.

Passerby Passerby said:

Only real complaint about the dark knight is that they cast this hagface to replace sexy as hell Katie Holmes in the first place. I can think of a dozen other actresses they could have gotten for this part that wouldn't have made me choke on my toulge everytime someone acused her of being beautiful.

lebitters lebitters said:

She looks terrible. I think she looks like the Dark Knight. I don't think Maggie is attractive, but I have seen her look at least cute. This does her no justice.

Annabel Annabel said:

Hate it :O
Its soo creapy looking :S

Passerby Passerby said:

I agree, she has a total grandma face. I always want to ask her for a cookie and get her a blanket.

<a href="/user/388" title="View user profile.">candyqueen</a>
300 points
candyqueen said:

i hate it
..................with kisses from the CandyQueen

kirsti kirsti said:

did anyone notice that her make-up is slightly reminiscent of the joker?

Passerby Passerby said:

she actually looks like the joker.. with the long chin, and the horrible eye make up! the smokie eye look isnt workign for her.. it looks runny.. she isnt very pretty to begin with, but this picture is UGHH!

Marivone Marivone said:

NICE! She looks like the fucking JOKER!!!! muhuhauhauhauhauhauaahu PERFECT! It suits her perfectly...

solarlove256
300 points
solarlove256 said:

Hate It!!

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This is to prove that you are a human, and not a spam bot.
4 + 1 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

When commenting, please be respectful to other INO readers. No racial, sexual or homophobic slurs will be tolerated.