Are we still in a day and age when people are shocked about lip synching? An official statement was released because Lady Gaga couldn’t keep up with the track she was singing over on Australia’s morning show, Sunrise.
It wasn’t "live". But she was singing. Lady Gaga was just singing over her song because of all the dancing she was doing.
What do you think about the statement? Are they throwing her under the bus? Or was the show really blind sighted by the act?
—
This morning’s performance from Lady Gaga was obviously not live.That
is a clear breach of Sunrise policy on music performances.We’d like
to apologise for the segment and assure you we view the breach
extremely seriously. We pride ourselves on our live music performances
and will continue to deliver Australian audiences with the best acts
from here and overseas.
Adam Boland
Executive Producer
The problem is many singers these days aren’t at all well-versed in breath control and the stamina needed to sing AND dance. They’ll opt to do one, or the other, and if they really want to pull off both they actually have to PRACTICE this. As in, running around constantly and getting used to catching your breath quickly while still sounding somewhat decent. When they Day 26 guys were doing vocal exercises while running up and down stairs in Central Park (I think) on their show, I understood why their coach was having them do it. Their choreography isn’t the craziest, but at least they end up better prepared to sound good while they dance.
Just posted the last comment (12:30), but totally agree with Ulf.. and also, what is Ashlee Simpson lip-synching for? She hardly dances, much less jumps wildly across the stage while performing… completely unwarranted – then she had the nerve to blame it on acid reflux. Blah.
Well, it doesn’t surprise me. Name me one dance music singer who can actually sing without the aid of a computer? It’s just the way it is and I don’t really care.
Hey, Riviera, just look at your avatar to see someone who doesn’t lip synch her live performances- Madonna doesn’t! And she’s 50, but she never has and works to make sure she has the stamina to be able to do it. She uses a back-up track for chorus vocals, but she sings every verse.
She actually does sing live. There was a mistake in setting up the track and the one with vocals was put on instead of the one without as she does not have a live band.
It’s the pop twits who can’t sing. They have no talent, and they just become famous because they are “hot”. That’s why I hate pop music. I know everyone has their own taste in music, but that’s why I prefer singer-songwriters and indie musicians. I definitely prefer going to see a really talented singer that only goes onstage with a guitar and a microphone as opposed to an overproduced dance recital where the “singer” is lip synching. Plus, the tickets are cheaper and the musicians actually give a crap about their fans.
LADY GAGA IS THE BEST! I HAVE SEEN HER PERFORM ON MANY, MANY, OCCASIONS AND THIS IS THE 1ST TIME I HAVE EVER HEARD HER LIPSYNCH. I’VE SEEN HER PERFORM IN AN INTIMATE SETTING CLUB IN NEW YORK AND SHE IS LOVELY.
Well, bitch, then this dial-a-diva must’ve either been seriously off her game or the only “intimate setting” you’ve ever seen her in was a Tijuana donkey show. They could’ve nabbed a tranny hooker off any corner and (s)he’d do at least as good a job. She put more effort into that hideous ensem than actual rehearsal. Maybe she was having a brain hemorrhage? That would explain the ungainly lurching and convulsing from one side of the stage to the next.
This is proof positive that you can put the publicity machine behind a glammed-up nobody but you can’t manufacture talent.
Is it me, or does the track sound like it’s been speed up? And, you can obviously tell that she’s singing, but her volume is barely even up, not able to overcome the background track. There’s various parts where it seems like she sings louder to try to outweigh the background track. Lady GaGa is very talented, can, and does, sing live. I honestly believe this was just a technical problem– nothing seemed right, at all, with the track and microphone.
anybody who know anything about television performance knows the the sound was controlled 100% by the sunrise staff, INCLUDING THE PRODUCERS. First of all, you can totally hear her singing (even though it isn’t very loud), and if anyone watched it live and not on you YOUTUBE THEY would have seen the show was cued at the wrong time…they panned to an empty stage, and cut to commercial, then came back with lady gaga’s performance. Perhaps the public apology that was made should have been to gaga for the amateur stage/television production, and perhaps you should view every other live performance she’s ever done ever to see that not only does she never lip sync but she’s incredible and famous for her live shows. its a shame a big network can’t take responsibility for their own technical/production difficulties and feel the need to blame it on the artist. can’t wait to see her on rove on sunday.
Well even Britney Spears may do some token “singing” over the playback, but that doesn’t mean she sounds at all good on her own. This chick is struggling to be heard. If her dancing was at least competent that would mitigate the situation, but it’s awkward at best. This looks like a talent show. The advent of music video is the problem. Before that, you didn’t necessarily have to be great-looking to top the charts. Now image is everything. It’s easy to make someone look polished and slick onscreen. I think a certain laziness has set in the music industry. Singers think it’s enough to just show up and look good while they mime their way through performances.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KlzP1c2z2yg
THERES THE CONTROVERSIAL PERFORMANCE =O!! DOUBLE CLICK TO SEE THE VIEW COUNT, ADD &fmt=18 TO THE END OF THE URL FOR HIGH QUALITY AND ALSO TO COMMENT!!
O M G!!
pop music will never be low brow
I really like Lady GaGa’s song ‘Just Dance’, but lip sync-ing is wrong. If she can’t dance and sing at the same time (which is understandable), then she should just have her back-up dancers dance. People know that artists often lip sync, but that doesn’t make it accepted or right.
Also, she really needs to think carefully about her wardrobe! She has a great figure, but not so great taste in clothing.
Maybe if she spent less time prancing around on stage and more time focusing on her singing she would have put on a better performance.
I blame her managers, don’t put her on stage to sing “live” when she can’t even keep up with the track.
They put her out there to hang herself, and that is exactly what she did. I saw that act and it was awful!
There are artists out there that are amazing live performers, some of these people are so brilliant that a recorded album doesn’t do them any justice.
Lip syncing is terrible, no one wants to spend their hard earned money watching someone pretend to sing!
Seriously, if you can’t dance and sing live at the same time, please don’t even try. A true artist can truely dance and sing live at the same time; Madonna, Mariah and Fergie did it. Lady Gaga is definitely NO LADY for walking out of a performance during air time. Lady Gaga is no artist, She doesn’t deserve to be in the chart. Lady Gaga should apologize to Sunrise.
Madonna did it?
Please when?
Everytime Madonna dance AND Sings live, the song is absolutely butchered (at least for the last 3 tours and 2 showcases I attended).
her performance on rove!!!
Christina Aguilera’s new look and this chick’s look are seperated at birth! I can;t believe how much they look alike!!! Strange.
If you can call what she did dancing.
OMIGOD! have you heard pokerface? cant read my, cant read my, no he cant read my pokerface!
xaxa…hard cheography..look she was just not DANCING..ARE U CRAZY..i can see britney lypsinging but she is DANCING!!!this girl just can not dance……..she was just lypsinging….!just..!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!xaax
like her hair,nature or tinct?
Wtf, who ever thinks she lyp syncs is a fucking idiot.
Britney Spears dances? You’re an idiot if you think that. And this was an old performance. If any of you have seen Gaga as of late, you’ll know that her performances are all live. Get over yourselves.
Have any of you people saying shes got no talent,because all of her songs are digitally edited actually seen her live????
Cause shes fucking far better than you,shes just as good anyway.Anyway,i’d like to see you dance moves you havn’t picked,and had to memorize of by heart.
Are we forgetting she can play piano and speaks fluently in like,5 diff languages??
Are we forgetting shes no sheep??
are we forgetting,she didn’t crack when those nasty hermaphrodite rumors were going around???
Exactly.Bet you never thought about that
Have any of you people saying shes got no talent,because all of her songs are digitally edited actually seen her live????
Cause shes fucking far better than you,shes just as good anyway.Anyway,i’d like to see you dance moves you havn’t picked,and had to memorize of by heart.
Are we forgetting she can play piano and speaks fluently in like,5 diff languages??
Are we forgetting shes no sheep??
are we forgetting,she didn’t crack when those nasty hermaphrodite rumors were going around???
Exactly.Bet you never thought about that
d6XIMC nlnpeskskxih, [url=http://jnxshqlwoxqc.com/]jnxshqlwoxqc[/url], [link=http://jjhrhqekknzf.com/]jjhrhqekknzf[/link], http://ulwqmfsseyjc.com/
health insurance plans fupmxx health insurance brdrl nj car insurance 3035 auto insurance blmkcy affordable health insurance 692637
buy xanax 027203 tramadol
(( auto insurance rates rbp xanax xly
carisoprodol lwk buy cheap meridia 83752 prednisone jnkwy auto insurance quote grihl
health insurance nhycem slots 109 auto insurance quotes tlfb group health insurance 88821
home insurance coverage 94838 colorado health insurance 909 group health insurance 675804 homeowner s insurance 023716 cheapest insurance =-P
tramadol >:DDD buy tramadol 8-] acomplia aczymw
levitra 356553 what is phentermine
accutane 00197 accutane >:DDD xanax :[[
auto insurance quotes =(( auto insurance %-]] nj car insurance jlq car insurance quotes 788
colorado health insurance 21186 cheap california auto insurance 0311 car insurance quotes 180 auto insurance uyfv
pharmacy college buy tramadol 287002 cheap ultram papt phentermine 8-] accutane shrmzv
buy propecia aysn what is prednisone used for 481903 how to take doxycycline 8-D Xanax online :]]
They probably got paid the tonne of money to show up, then lip synced it, very badly.
performing live and recording a song in the studio are compeltely different things! You would have to be pretty naive to believe that these singers sound the same and after all the digital editing that goes into their records. if a performer is truly a musician, they should sing live. I have never seen the symphony pretend to perform over their own recordings. maybe that’s because they actually have talent!?
xihEsSRY
Also here is her latest single:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_JssKIr2Iu4
ZtnfqN
singers never sound the same live! I’d rather hear good music sung live than horrible singing over tracks and sloppy choreography. what happened to the good ol’ days of performers actually having TALENT?
you should check out beyonce’s performances, along with pink, shakira,& kelly clarkson. these are some real DIVAS that can be called professionals for they do sing well while dancing, specially beyonce…….PS. even molly cyrus is an overall more proffessional performer than lady gaga
NgdKQfVU
Almost every singer/performer does it at some point. Especially when they are dancing on stage. They’d be totally out of breath and unable to keep up with the song. It STILL grates on my last nerve that Ashlee Simpson gets flak about the SNL thing. Nearly all performers lip synch on there. There’s even an episode with Eminem where it is sooo obvious and there wasn’t ever backlash about his. It’s ridiculous. Nobody sounds perfect live -especially when there’s movement/choreography involved.
He was like the next performer after Ashlee’s thing happened!! and no one said a damn thing. They almost all use support vocals, who can sing dancing like that? Yep totally agree with you here CL.
Last I checked, Asshole Simpson wasn’t dancing during her performances… or at least not on the crappy ones she did on SNL. What’s the excuse now, why the voice over track?? I’ll even give Eminem a break since he’s actually RAPPING – therefore rapping that fast and then having to go into a chorus break may take the wind out of you.
Ashlee had no excuse. Facts are facts, she’s garbage.
errrr that is so untrue
look at hayley williams from paramore
she has an amzing voice.
she runs around stage
headbanging and jumping around
working up a solid sweat yet still can sing like a goddess
Most award shows, like the American Music awards and MTV Video awards and Teen Choice the performers lip sync. A few years ago Beyonce did a song where she hung up side down and didn’t even bother with the microphone…seriously and everyone was raving about her ability to sing up side down. When a show says ‘live’ you kind of hope that there is some real singing going on somewhere. The only time I get really ticked off, is when I pay the high cost of a concert ticket to see someone perform live, and all I get is lip syncing. I’d rather see less dancing and coreography from the headliner than hear a taped version…that’s not what I paid for.
How the hell can you bring Beyonce into this? Upside down???
STOP acting like she lip-synced the entire performance. & she DID have a mic! WTH were you looking @??? The amazing part was the fact she went through TWO songs dancing & singing the entire time.
& before any rebuttals are posted
here’s a link to her performing the SAME two songs on Oprah… LIVE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x79NOtriyvc
She is like the ONLY performer out now with high energy, choreographed dancing & LIVE vocal performances. Get a grip.
Please save that BS for these robots that can’t sing LIVE while standing still, let alone while dancing! & you know who I’m referring to.
yeah, i thought it was pretty understood that when someone is doing heavy choreography they aren’t really singing….BUT i’m not familiar with lady gaga (horrible name) so i’m not sure how heavy her choreography is.
Remember the days when people did sang live – oh the good ole days!! It’s mainly this generation people (mainly pop) are lip synching – what a joke. Nobody need talent any more and I find that very sad.
All these pop stars want to have their cake and eat it, too. If you can’t sing because you’re dancing too hard, then become a dancer! Why do you present yourself as a singer?
It’s because everybody wants to be a “triple-threat”: singer, dancer, actor…clothing designer, perfume creator, executive producer, astronaut, blah blah blah…Just do one thing and do it well.
But anyway…no one forces me to listen to this stuff and I guess it’ll always be around so, no need to get too upset…
How come Tina Turner can sing and dance live when she’s in her 60s, but all these bimbos in their 20s have to be overdubbed or else they sound out-of- breath? There was a time when breath control was actually part a singer’s training. People who do stage work have to pull it off.
The reason people came down so hard on Simpson was because she made such a point of bemoaning overdubbing and swore she never does it. You know, just she doesn’t do cosmetic surgery and publicity stunt marriages.
R U KIDDING?
caca can’t speak italian even with the most expensive trainers of NY and NJ.
v3b54u ayomqlzaormo, [url=http://glcjguosmeyz.com/]glcjguosmeyz[/url], [link=http://hhdemarfkpph.com/]hhdemarfkpph[/link], http://tmmjjemdkitq.com/
It’s one thing to be a terrible singer in real life who relies on ProTools and pitch correction to sound good (Britney Spears) and quite another to be someone who has an amazing voice and doesn’t need studio assistance. Lady Gaga has proven that she can sing live…and amazingly at that. On that basis alone, I’m a bit more forgiving to Gaga singing alongside a track. I saw her the other night at MSG and during songs where there was an incredible amount of dancing she was singing alongside a track, but her voice could still be made out. However on songs like speechless, you and I, and several others where she was stationary, her voice soared. It’s people like Spears that I can’t stand because they are terrible singers who don’t sing a single note live because they are horrid and are selling an image only.
home insurance coverage =-)) business insurance pvwy cheap health insurance :]] health insurance 51548
home owners insurance in florida %DDD florida auto insurance 017886 private health insurance :]]] nevada homeowners insurance quote kodta a auto insurance tpa
cheap cialis sale online 379 ambien ksvzb acomplia jpfs buy cheap acomplia vsc
denavir cjuwhl where to buy evista :] norvasc woec
meridia reviews 920 tramadol =-OO xanax usqmy buy phentermine >:-DDD xanax without prescription >:-PP
accutane online pharmacy tmssnl tramadol =-]] prednisone 8-DD acomplia miracle diet pill 6513 ultram 8(((
uFepLMKw
This thread is OLD. The Performance was since 2008, during the starting days of Lady GaGa. She have proven her talent for the past 2 years already. DO NOT COMMENT ANYMORE. Please trash/junk this thread…
jefferson pilot life insurance kxzqb manufactured home insurance =-[[ free health insurance 69323 business insurance isvvbx
online car insurance 79682 car insurance quotes 353 flexeril %-PPP health insurance quotes endknz phentermine
P
slots 327 health insurance providers tzaekm health insurance %-PP auto insurance 8-P