O.M.G. I love her shoes!!!!!!!!!!!

Of course I would love to have a body like Jessica's. She looks great. Carrie is pretty also but has more of a kids body.

That picture of Danni Lynn is too cute, she looks just like her mom.

I NEED Jessica's shoes in my life.

This story is so lame. Jennifer Hudson just lost her family and they put this crap on the cover? If it's true, Carrie sounds really petty. She is naturally a curvy girl so she should not be knocking Jessica. The rags need to find more believeable stories.

If this is true, then does Carrie remember how fat she was when she was on American Idol? She was more "buxom" than Jessica will ever be. This is the same girl who was milking cows and talking about how she'd never been on a plane before and this was only 3 or 4 short years ago.

Both beautiful girls, love both of there music. Im done. But you know what upsets and annoys me. They put that BS right on the cover and have Jennifer Hudsons tragedy on the side. I'm sure she'd much rather it nt be front page news but when that rag think its more important they sell magazines with a country catfight and not report about Jennifer, an extremely talented beautiful woman, who's life and familys life have been torn apart

so let me get this right. if a magazine constantly pins you against another woman then that automatically makes you rivals? r these ppl serious? i doubt very seriously carrie said that and even if she did, would she be stupid enough to say it to a magazine? and who cares how carrie got her start? look at how many lives have been changed because of that silly reality show. at least her daddy isn't in control of her career. i would rather listen to her voice over jessica's breathy singing any day. do ppl really think jessica would be doing country if she hadn't failed at pop or whatever the hell that was she was singing? jessica goes around acting dingy, like paris, all because she thinks its cute. correct me if i am wrong, but didn't jessica grow up in the south as well- milking cows and collecting chicken eggs. i am sure she grew up in texas. btw, carrie's body looks amazing in that dress and looks more buxum.

Carrie looks like an underweight 14 year old boy who shaved his legs and put on heels and a poofy-bodiced dress for Halloween.
She should stick to singing and talk less.
Damn her for making me defend JS!

they are both way to skinny, at least on the magazine.

If Carrie said that Jessica is fat, I wonder if it is because Carrie has an eating disorder and really thinks that way. When Carrie was on American Idol and shortly after I thought she was very attractive. However, she became one of those "Hollywood types" ( interesting for such a "country" girl) who decided that looking like a 10 year old boy is an attractive look for a female. I don't know what happened, but she used to look like a woman. She is now a "lollipop head" with NO body at all.

this is gay. i hope they both gain 200lbs and then see what they will say about eachother.

fuck

Since when is someone Jessica's size "fat" in the first place? People like Carrie Underwood are influential and don't realize the damage they are doing to young girls! We wonder why teenage girls have eating disorders!!!

Let's start celebrating women, real women, of all shapes, sizes, and colors! It's about time we start appreciating what God gave us instead of insulting it!

I have to say that Carrie looks the best in the picture. More feminine. Jessica looks terrible in that dress. Hair all pulled back slick against her head. The shoes are sorry too. Normally she looks feminine. The sad fact is, they are both very pretty young women and this "fight" is made up for publicity. Don't buy it folks. They may not be friends, but the lengths these rag mags go to in order to make a buck is amazing! As far as singing, Carrie can sing and Jessica needs lessons.

First of all, let me say, I would cut off my arm to look like either one of them, but the expression "beauty is as beauty does" comes to mind. I think Tony's head has been jolted around a bit too much or something. Jessica has got to be one of the most annoying people alive. Ahhh yes....I remember back oh 10 years ago or so when she was pushing her virginity thing, before her and Nick were married, all the while shooting music videos with little to nothing on and wrapping her legs around Nick, pleaseeee!!! I think Carrie at least has some class and doesn't act like she is completely brain dead. She is talented and beautiful and doesn't need Tony. I mean who would really want a guy who wants a girl with the mentality of cardboard and has to be controlled by her daddy. Sorry....off track a bit....the too fat issue? Who cares? They both look great.

You know, I find it interesting that there are really really big famous girls who are not white out there that make Jessica look anorexic. Why does everyone pick on white girls? You'd never see a mexican or african american battling it out about who's a** is bigger. So so shallow. Carrie is awful. She would not be anywhere without American Idol. I've actually seen the girl in public (i live in Nashville) and she wears more makeup than anyone I've ever seen. She's also about 5'1, not 5'3.

This is just great slimy slugs like you calling someone who makes millions of $$$$$$$$$$$$$$ a year compared to your probably 20K.