Fact Or Fiction: Carrie Underwood Calls Jessica Simpson Fat

Fact Or Fiction: Carrie Underwood Calls Jessica Simpson Fat

Oh no she didn't!  A friend of Carrie Underwood's said she called Jessica Simpson fat after looking at Jess' magazine cover proclaiming her love for Tony Romo.

She finds Jessica’s love of putting her life on display pretty desperate,” a pal of the “Before He Cheats” singer tells OK!. "She laughed at the People cover, because it’s the same one Jess did about John Mayer — same smile, same look, except she’s a little fatter.”

Carrie also isn't worried about competition in the country music field.

“Carrie doesn’t think fans will spend money to watch Jess warble through a few badly written songs.” 

Carrie seems like such a sweet girl.  Do you think she truly feels this way or is the media just exaggerating this blondie battle? So, fact or fiction: Did Carrie really call Jessica fat???



Click here to return to the home page.


divider

 62 Comments

<a href="/user/427" title="View user profile.">annielovesfred</a>annielovesfred said:
Carrie may seem like a sweet girl, but she's still a GIRL. so 'oh yes she did' fat fat fat!
ShaiShay (not verified)ShaiShay (not verified) said:
Yeah, Carrie seems like such a stuck up snot. Shes so annoying and shes not even country. Im sick of hearing her sappy songs on the radio. And someone please tell her she doesnt have to be the main character in EVERY ****ing video! GO JESS
<a href="/user/311" title="View user profile.">Ellie</a>Ellie said:
Wouldn't be surprised. She puts on a front just like everyone else. I'm sure she's not a "sweet girl" 24 hours a day. And yes, I absolutely believe that she would call someone fat. She does have an eating disorder... it's very obvious.
Anonymous (not verified)Anonymous (not verified) said:
UM no she doesnt have an eating disorder you stupid skank bitch. go douche your **** bitch
Shayna (not verified)Shayna (not verified) said:
haha, jealous much? Anyways, I know carrie..I'm in her fc..and have met her NUMEROUS times...and shes not that way at all. Shes a gracious nice girl who is nothing but awesome to her fans! I don't care what any of you say, unless u know someone don't make assumptions. The media is totally trying to play this up and make it worse than it really is. She does nothing but defend those around her all the time..shes'd NEVER say anything like this. And for all of you who "think" you know who Carrie is....go look in the mirror and sweep around your own porch before you point out the dirt on someone elses!
<a href="/user/1529" title="View user profile.">C.Mo</a>C.Mo said:
Wow catty much Carrie? I think she's still hung up on Tony.
Anonymous (not verified)Anonymous (not verified) said:
Carrie is remorseful for dumping Tony, and she only has herself to blame. Jessica is dating him now, and he is happy according to reports. She needs to move on with her life already. I am not a fan of Carrie's and if she did call Jessica fat, I agree with her totally! Jessica needs to take her little brain dead ass to the gym, and carry herself like the celeb she is!
Anonymous (not verified)Anonymous (not verified) said:
I agree with Carrie. Tony Romo totally downgraded when he went from a real country singer with a rockin body and cuter face to a copy-cat fatty like Jessica.
wow! (not verified)wow! (not verified) said:
I know a bunch of people find jessica annoying and blah blah blah, but I feel bad for her! and Vera... are you kidding... Carrie? sweet? She seems like the ultimate bitch. Ever since she won American Idol and has become "oh so famous" she thinks her **** doesn't stink! Just by lookin at her grins and the faces she makes, you can just tell lol. buh buh buh buh- BITCH!
<a href="/user/1507" title="View user profile.">cybera</a>cybera said:
Sometimes saying someone is "a little fatter" does not mean you think they are fat. Similarly, saying someone is "a little thinner" does not mean you think they are thin. Still not a nice thing to say, but you never know what she really meant (if she even said it).
<a href="/user/4059" title="View user profile.">Emily</a>Emily said:
Yes, she probably did say this. But who hasn't ever looked at a magazine cover and made a comment about someone's body, whether too fat or too skinny? I don't think there's anything wrong with her having said this to a "friend" who then tried to paint her as some malicious bitch by leaking it to the media.
<a href="/user/453" title="View user profile.">Selena</a>Selena said:
I think Carrie Underwood probably told "this person" thinking that it wouldnt go any further than just girl talk. I wouldnt go as far as calling Jessica Simpson fat but I think she is a little desperate to find love and when she thinks she does she has to let everyone know. It really just makes her look like a fool.
Brenda3 (not verified)Brenda3 (not verified) said:
Carrie is so not sweet. I heard her on the radio talking about Jessica and tony and she practically called Tony stupid for going out with Tony. It was so cringeworthy -That is when I realised she is a bitch through and through. I'll try find it. I completely believe she would call Jessica fat and I still think she should not have made that Allure comment about someone else's boyfriend.
lam0210 (not verified)lam0210 (not verified) said:
Brenda3, I listened to the whole interview and no where did Carrie say anything derogative about either Tony or Jessica. The DJs were trying to get her to say things and even tried putting words in her mouth but Carrie didn't bit on it. She tried to direct the things at her so that they would not be put on Tony or Jessica. So BACK OFF!
wow! (not verified)wow! (not verified) said:
there is nothing wrong with letting the world know you are in love, even if it annoys the world, lol. if it makes her happy to tell all, then let her!
<a href="/user/4902" title="View user profile.">Terry Berry</a>Terry Berry said:
~Terry~ She might have buI still thimk Jessica is a beautiful women. She can not be that dumb to have accomplished so much.
<a href="/user/509" title="View user profile.">operaghost</a>operaghost said:
Have heard enough rumors about Carrie Underwood to give me pause and think this could have happened . . . though if she intended for the "friend" to out the comment in the tabs just to continue her jabs toward Jessica, it can't help but backfire. Carrie's coming off as mean, Jessica is coming off as a little lost and insecure, and neither one of them are being helped by any of this. Keep your business to yourselves, girls, and get on with your lives. Oh, and Jessica is not fat. Carrie is, however, underweight.
Anony (not verified)Anony (not verified) said:
doubt she said this, but if she did it's not like she would be lying
laurain (not verified)laurain (not verified) said:
i want to drop a long poop on carries face
Anonymous123 (not verified)Anonymous123 (not verified) said:
well Jessica is getting a little bit chubby so I wouldn't be surprise if she said that. I really don't think they like each other very much.
chuckles (not verified)chuckles (not verified) said:
FICTION. According to a CMT reporter Carrie was vacationing in Europe last week so she probably hasn't even seen last week's People. Carrie's bent over backwards to defend people like Faith Hill, Leann Rimes, and Miranda Lambert. She's good friends with Kellie Pickler who always talks about how sweet Carrie is. Taylor Swift said Carrie's the one person who doesn't say bad things about anybody no matter what they've said about her. This is just OK magazine being bitter that Carrie refuses to participate in any feud story.
<a href="/user/700" title="View user profile.">LN</a>LN said:
Ok, Jessica is NOT fat! Who are you nutty people!
wow! (not verified)wow! (not verified) said:
Laurain.. I agree, right down her throat so she can shut her rude mouth up!
Brenda3 (not verified)Brenda3 (not verified) said:
here is the radio interview. She starts talking about Tony and Jessica around around 3.58mins www.kase101.com/cc-common/mediaplayer/player.html?redir=yes&mps=&mid=http://a1135.g.akamai.net/f/1135/23782/1h/cchannel.download.akamai.com/23782/736/richmedia/kase_skim_07-38.mp3?CCOMRRMID=15497231&CPROG=RICHMEDIA&MARKET=AUSTIN-TX&NG_FORMAT=country&NG_ID=kase101fm&OR_NEWSFORMAT=&OWNER=736&SERVER_NAME=www.kase101.com&SITE_ID=736&STATION_ID=KASE-FM&TRACK=Carrie_Underwood_INT See the 'Im a little more country' comments. LOL
<a href="/user/2085" title="View user profile.">Lizzypoo</a>Lizzypoo said:
It's a girl and an ex thing. It's no biggie. She was just talking to a friend. I don't compliment my exes new flames.
sazzy (not verified)sazzy (not verified) said:
personally i dont think carrie underwood has grounds to say anything bad about jessica simpson. Jessica is a gorgeous girl and Carrie Underwood is boreing and got lucky with bulimia. She used to be quite pudgy on AI so if I were her I would watch my mouth. Shes just jealous anyway
Mell Mell (not verified)Mell Mell (not verified) said:
LOL....Oh no she dih-int!
Anonymous (not verified)Anonymous (not verified) said:
I think the media is trying to put these two against each other. Jessica has stated their is no beef between them. If I had to choose one it would Carrie.
<a href="/user/945" title="View user profile.">Jo Jo Pop</a>Jo Jo Pop said:
Holy cow - I never realized Jessica Simpson had so many supporters!! Anyway, I'm going with Chuckles on this one. I totally think this is fiction. Carrie Underwood doesn't seem like the type to say that at all. I think she comes off as so nice and not at all catty. Also, she seems to want to stay out of the spotlight, unlike Jessica who grabs any attention she can get. And people who unjustly accuse others of having eating disorders should be ashamed of themselves. Eating disorders are a serious problem and not something that should just be thrown around. Just because someone is skinny doesn't make them sick.
<a href="/user/465" title="View user profile.">Shanhole</a>Shanhole said:
Eh, not sure if I should believe it or not. If I HAD to choose - Jessica.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Filtered words will be replaced with the filtered version of the word.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This is to prove that you are a human, and not a spam bot.
7 + 4 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
Join Our Email List
Email:  
For Email Marketing you can trust